Lessons from Lisbon: Your Program Design Isn't Your Value Anymore. Now What?
If a machine can write the program, what is a client paying you for? Carl and James on what coaches wrestled with at the first OPEX Coach Retreat.
Frameworks with Carl Hardwick | CoachRx Podcast Network
Frameworks, Episode 55, with Carl Hardwick and James FitzGerald
If a machine can write a better training program and a better nutrition plan than you can, what exactly is a client paying you for?
That question sat in the middle of the room at the OPEX Coach Retreat in Portugal. OPEX Coaches joined Carl Hardwick and James FitzGerald for the first OPEX Coach Retreat. It was not three days of assessment and program design education. It was a week of living, eating, training, and arguing together about where the coach's value sits now.
In Episode 55, Carl and James unpack what came out of it. Here are the lessons worth sitting with.
1. Stop holding on to what you think makes you valuable
James kept returning to one word all week: progressive. His definition is simple. A progressive coach lets go of what has calcified.
He sorts a coach's tools into three silos: exercise, nutrition, and behavior. Then he asks coaches to accept a premise. The machine does individual exercise prescription and nutrition prescription better than you can today.
If that's true, there is one silo left. "You have to quadruple down on being as human as possible," James says. That means the relationship. Knowledge acquisition. Creativity, intuition, patience. Graduation toward independence.
"It's the only card we have."
2. Exercise and nutrition are simpler than we made them
James reduced nutrition to three words in the room: eat real food. He watched it land hard.
Many coaches built their identity on their own transformation, then built a complex system around it. Macro counting. Testing. Protocols. Hearing that the answer is simple feels like a strike against who they are.
Carl owned OPEX's part in this on the exercise side. For years the conversation was dose response and the last one percent of program design. "We went far enough," he says. "Let's simplify it, and let's re-aim to this behavior stuff."
James's test for every coach: is it simple in your own life? If it is, why are you making it complex for your client?
The complexity is real. It just lives somewhere else. It lives in the person across the desk, in what they value, and in why they aren't doing the simple thing they already know.
3. Program design is labor, and labor is getting cheaper
Midweek, Carl and Casey showed the room what is coming to CoachRx. Afterward Carl had at least a dozen conversations that started the same way: "I think my service offering has to change."
His point on the episode is blunt. Designing training and nutrition programs is labor, and that labor gets less valuable over time. As impressive as the demo was, he says, "it's going to be a lot better in ten days."
James puts it this way: "We're all going to be AI managers. If it's not five years, it's ten years." So accept it and get ahead of it. Let the system handle prescription. Spend your hours on the conversations only a human can have.
Carl offered a useful twist. Is doubling down on the human relationship progressive, or is it a return to something people have always wanted? Either way, his line is clear. Automate what should be automated, and "fight and claw" to keep the rest.
4. Write down graduation
Carl left Lisbon and changed his client lifecycle model. Next to churn, he added a second arrow: graduation.
A client who churns goes through the whole loop again with another coach or another gym. A client who graduates leaves able to do this on their own. Carl wants coaches to track both, celebrate one, and learn from the other.
James goes a step further. In his definition, a graduate can teach others. "When you write down graduation, it changes everything," he says. The conversation with a client stops being reactive and starts being about what they are learning.
The usual objection is the business model. Carl says the numbers hold. Length of stay, LTV, and retention are not hurt by graduation, and in many cases they improve, because clients stay until they get there. And as James points out, there are plenty of people who still need a coach.
5. You can't do this work from a distance
At breakfast one morning James told Carl, "We could never do it any other way."
A hard exchange at 3 PM was followed by dinner with the same person at 6 PM, talking about their family. Nobody could leave the conversation. That is the consult room, scaled up. Challenge and support, in the same seat.
It was also the proof of the week's argument. The relationship is not a soft skill beside the real work. It is the work.
Listen to the full episode
Carl and James go deeper on all of this in Episode 55, Lessons from Lisbon. Next week they take on the idea underneath it: the learning relationship between coach and client.
Listen to Episode 55 Now
Watch on YouTube Listen on Spotify Catch up on past episodes + blog recaps
Where to go from here
Build the whole coach. The behavior work Carl and James kept returning to in Lisbon is a skill, and it can be learned. The OPEX Method is one program covering behavior, assessment, lifestyle, nutrition, exercise, and business, for coaches who have decided this is their career.
Learn more about the OPEX Method
Put your hours where they count. If prescription is the part a system can carry, use one built on coaching principles. CoachRx holds your assessment, program design, and client communication in one place, so more of your time goes to the person across the desk.
Frameworks is part of the CoachRx Podcast Network, your hub for principled, purpose-driven coaching conversations.
For more shows, visit: coachrx.app/podcast-network
More in Frameworks.
Deliver the coaching
you're capable of.
Try CoachRx free and see what changes when every part of your practice is in the same place.
