AMA CoachRx Weekly Challenge: Addressing Push-Pull Imbalances: A Coach's Guide to Shoulder Health and Performance
Addressing Push-Pull Imbalances: A Coach's Guide to Shoulder Health and Performance
As fitness coaches, we've all encountered clients with noticeable strength disparities between pushing and pulling movements. These imbalances can significantly impact performance, movement quality, and long-term shoulder health. When a client uses the same weight on both sides despite visible asymmetries, it presents a complex coaching challenge that requires systematic assessment and thoughtful programming.
James FitzGerald of OPEX Fitness recently addressed this common coaching dilemma in his AMA series, providing valuable insights that align with what successful coaches implement in practice. His perspective emphasizes individualized assessment and the fundamental importance of push-pull balance for shoulder health and injury prevention.
Why Push-Pull Balance Matters in Program Design
Experienced coaches recognize that pushing and pulling represent opposing movement patterns that should generally maintain relative balance for optimal function. This equilibrium becomes particularly critical around the shoulder complex, where imbalances frequently manifest as pain, dysfunction, or eventually, injury.
As FitzGerald emphasizes, "We want that balance regardless of ability over time for safety of the shoulder." This statement reflects what many of us have observed in our coaching practices—clients with significant push-pull imbalances tend to develop shoulder issues more frequently than those with balanced strength profiles.
While sport-specific training may sometimes intentionally create certain imbalances, general fitness programming should maintain conscious awareness of push-pull ratios. Even when prioritizing movement quality over pure strength metrics, local muscular balance remains a foundational consideration.
Practical Assessment Strategies
Before implementing corrective programming, effective coaches utilize systematic assessment procedures to identify specific imbalances. These assessments provide objective data upon which to base programming decisions.
Isometric Position Assessments
Plank variations offer valuable diagnostic information about shoulder stability and symmetry:
Front Plank: Observe scapular positioning and the ability to maintain active protraction
Reverse Plank: Assess thoracic extension capability and scapular retraction
Side Plank: Evaluate lateral stability and side-to-side differences in endurance
When administering these assessments, pay particular attention to compensatory patterns. A client's ability to maintain position with proper scapular positioning provides valuable insights into functional shoulder strength and potential imbalances.
Range of Motion Assessments
The active range-of-motion scratch test offers additional diagnostic information:
Observe side-to-side differences in reaching capability
Note compensatory patterns during reaching movements
Document baseline measures to track improvements over time
Dynamic Movement Assessment
If static and range-of-motion assessments reveal potential imbalances, dynamic testing provides further confirmation:
Single-arm dumbbell rows: Assess pulling strength and unilateral differences
Single-arm chest press: Evaluate pushing strength and stabilization capability
Single-arm shoulder press: Observe overhead stability and strength discrepancies
Programming Solutions for Imbalance Correction
Once assessment reveals specific imbalances, strategic programming becomes essential. The simplest and most effective approach involves:
Establishing baseline loads with the weaker limb
Matching volume and load between sides (even though the stronger side could handle more)
Maintaining this approach until balance improves
Gradually incorporating bilateral movements as symmetry develops
This balanced approach prevents further development of compensatory patterns while allowing the weaker side to catch up through consistent training.
Recognizing Professional Boundaries
Responsible coaches understand when a client's imbalances exceed their scope of practice. Some asymmetries stem from neurological factors, chronic adaptations to specific activities (like the "violinist example" FitzGerald mentions), or previous injuries that may require specialized intervention.
Even when referring clients to appropriate specialists, coaches maintain their role in providing balanced programming that promotes symmetrical development. The goal isn't always perfect symmetry, but rather functional balance that supports movement quality and reduces injury risk.
Leveraging CoachRx for Imbalance Management
Managing client imbalances becomes significantly more effective with CoachRx's specialized features that support assessment, tracking, and program design:
Assessment Documentation and Tracking
CoachRx's assessment functionality allows coaches to:
Create custom assessments specific to push-pull imbalances
Document baseline measures with notes and observations
Track progress over time with comparison features
Store photos of postural assessments for visual reference
This comprehensive documentation creates accountability and allows for objective measurement of improvements rather than relying on memory or subjective impressions.
Individualized Exercise Programming
The platform's exercise programming features support imbalance correction through:
Single-side exercise prescription with specific loads for each side
Exercise variation tagging to ensure balanced movement selection
Tempo and volume control specific to each movement pattern
Progression tracking to ensure methodical advancement
These features allow coaches to implement the "weaker side first" approach with precision while maintaining detailed records of each client's progress.
Client Education Tools
Successful imbalance correction requires client understanding and buy-in. CoachRx facilitates this through:
Exercise demonstration videos showing proper form
Program notes explaining the rationale behind balanced training
Communication features for addressing client questions
Resource sharing capabilities for educational materials
When clients understand the "why" behind single-side training and balanced programming, their adherence naturally improves.
Long-Term Program Design
CoachRx's planning features support the progressive nature of imbalance correction:
Phase-based programming that systematically addresses asymmetries
Proper periodization that incorporates assessment checkpoints
Exercise progression pathways from unilateral to bilateral movements
Program templates that maintain push-pull balance as a foundation
This structured approach ensures that balance isn't just addressed in isolation but becomes integrated into the client's overall training philosophy.
Implementing a Balanced Approach
To apply these principles in coaching practice:
Conduct thorough push-pull assessments for all new clients
Document findings in CoachRx's assessment section
Design initial programming that addresses identified imbalances
Track progress systematically through regular reassessment
Gradually transition toward balanced bilateral training as symmetry improves
This methodical process creates the foundation for long-term shoulder health while establishing movement quality that supports future performance goals.
As James FitzGerald emphasizes, attention to push-pull balance represents fundamental coaching responsibility rather than an optional programming consideration. By implementing these strategies with the support of CoachRx's features, coaches can address imbalances systematically while providing clients with a clear understanding of how balanced training contributes to their overall fitness journey.
To explore more insights from James FitzGerald, watch his full AMA on addressing strength imbalances. For hands-on experience with how CoachRx can streamline your imbalance assessment and correction protocols, start a free trial today.
Ultimate Tech Stack for Fitness Coaches
1️⃣ CoachRx – Your Coaching Command Center.
2️⃣ OPEX CCP – Mentor-Guided Coaching Mastery.
3️⃣ LearnRx – On-Demand Coaching Education.
Explore the Tools to Elevate Your Coaching Today!
Now go out there and build the coaching business you’ve always dreamed of.
Ready to transform your coaching practice? Your journey to program design mastery starts here.
Start Your Free Trial with CoachRx Today
✅ All features unlocked
✅ Free transition assistance
✅ Quick setup support
✅ Immediate impact on your practice
Transform your program design. Elevate your coaching. Design your success.
Your future as a successful, in-demand coach starts now!
Stay ahead of the curve and provide the best for your clients with CoachRx and RxBot.
